Page 1 of 2

Cohh's Pokemon Game Stream Poll

Posted: Sat Jul 28, 2018 11:41 am
by nuuriell
Cohh will be playing two Pokemon games as rewards for the GuardianCon charity stream rewards; he would like you to vote on which TWO he will play. Let us know!

nuu

Re: Cohh's Pokemon Game Stream Poll

Posted: Sat Jul 28, 2018 1:00 pm
by xXxRevanxXx
15 out of these 16 choices are the same game for crying out loud :cohhLUL:

Re: Cohh's Pokemon Game Stream Poll

Posted: Sat Jul 28, 2018 1:49 pm
by aFatSoftDogBelly
WHY VOTING RED :( ? THAT GAME DOES NOT SUIT STREAMING:
- BAD GRAPHICS.
- NO DARK / STEEL / FAIRY
- PSYCHIC OVERPOWERED
- NO SPECIAL ATK / DEF. AND OTHER IMPORTANT GAMING MECHANICS

:biblethump:

Finally Cohh gets to play pokemon game. I hope it wont be red :(

Re: Cohh's Pokemon Game Stream Poll

Posted: Sun Jul 29, 2018 11:31 am
by darasilverdragon
Because for someone who doesn't play pokemon games a lot, Pokemon Red was absolutely seminal to the pokemon universe, and just dumping him into one of the later versions with no background in the series would be making him miss a lot of context
Plus, red had only 152 pokemon not counting missingno, and I feel like it would be a bad idea to overwhelm Cohh with the... what... 400+ ones that there are now?

Re: Cohh's Pokemon Game Stream Poll

Posted: Sun Jul 29, 2018 11:33 am
by MrBelb
I voted for Pokemon Red, but im really voting for the GBA "Fire Red" Version. Its way better for streaming and I really think you should consider playing that version. :cohhL:

Re: Cohh's Pokemon Game Stream Poll

Posted: Sun Jul 29, 2018 11:43 am
by Parrotflakes
Just a little tip: should you decide to play Red / Blue or Silver / Gold, there are updated versions of the games - FireRed / LeafGreen (GBA) and SoulSilver / HeartGold (DS) respectively. The updates include fixed bugs, more on-screen colors, improved graphics, and additional mechanics in and out of battle. The newer versions are essentially the same game, in a casual sense. :cohhGG:

Re: Cohh's Pokemon Game Stream Poll

Posted: Sun Jul 29, 2018 12:14 pm
by RangerOfVoid
Having one of the games he does as Red or Blue is a way to kick it back to the very beginning of pokemon, a feel for the roots. Though since it sounds like there is a remastered version for those two, that is an option as well. Plus Red and Blue is a big nostalgia factor for some of us. Though just wait until Cohh trys to get all the pokemon and finds out he needs the other color to trade with!

Re: Cohh's Pokemon Game Stream Poll

Posted: Sun Jul 29, 2018 2:58 pm
by Macawo
Voting for first and third Generation. Although I'd personally want to see him play the remake of the first and third Gen for better graphics and animations. So yeah, same game but better looks

Re: Cohh's Pokemon Game Stream Poll

Posted: Sun Jul 29, 2018 9:30 pm
by Seanemone
I would really like to see him play Heart Gold/ Soul Silver cause they have my favourite starter and legendaries while also being at least a little recent so the graphics aren't half bad in comparison. :cohhHmm:

The newest might be interesting too just cause I haven't actually played it myself. But official vote: Soul Silver! :cohhH: :cohhH:

Re: Cohh's Pokemon Game Stream Poll

Posted: Mon Jul 30, 2018 6:17 am
by RagnarozSR
@nuuriell Why are same gen games different options in the poll? It doesn't really matter if Cohh plays Red, Blue or Yellow, they're all the same game with minor differences. Having them be separate just dilutes the pool.

Re: Cohh's Pokemon Game Stream Poll

Posted: Mon Jul 30, 2018 7:44 am
by Belutima
nuuriell wrote:
Sat Jul 28, 2018 11:41 am
Cohh will be playing two Pokemon games as rewards for the GuardianCon charity stream rewards; he would like you to vote on which two he will play. Let us know!

nuu
I feel like there are some critical games missing like the 3rd version of some Generations like Crystal, the improved version of Gold and Silver.
or Platinum, the best version of that gens Diamand and Pearl. making
The 3rd iteration of the generation is most of the time an expansion.

Or perhaps some of the remakes that came later.

Not sure if these were left out because the games not available to cohh. or the poll cant have that many options.
But some big games are missing out, mainly the Later remakes of previous games. or upgraded version or sequels like Black 2 and White 2

But with Red winning I am assuming its Fire Red, Remake, and not the original Red.

Hope it becomes clear for cohh,

Re: Cohh's Pokemon Game Stream Poll

Posted: Mon Jul 30, 2018 8:17 am
by Weaver40k
I feel like these options should be grouped up instead of having red and blue, or gold and silver separate. If red gets first and blue gets second, he'll end up playing the same game twice. Also no remakes like soul silver?

Re: Cohh's Pokemon Game Stream Poll

Posted: Mon Jul 30, 2018 8:56 am
by suny_gaming
why is ultra sun / ultra moon missing but the regular versions with less content are in? or is that wrong information i have o.O

Re: Cohh's Pokemon Game Stream Poll

Posted: Mon Jul 30, 2018 8:59 am
by aFatSoftDogBelly
-Remakes arent included
-Lot's of main games arent included (Crystal, Ultra Sun / Moon, Black 2 / White 2, Omega Ruby/ Alpha Sapphire etc...)
-Lot's of other Pokemon titles are missing:
* Pokemon Ranger
* Colosseum
* Stadium
* Battle Revolution
* Mystery Dungeon
* Let's Go Pikachu / Eevee - He can play with Laina on stream and Cohh already has a switch!

Re: Cohh's Pokemon Game Stream Poll

Posted: Mon Jul 30, 2018 9:03 am
by RagnarozSR
Sero got it right in the previous thread. This is what I think the poll should look like and that would make a lot more sense. The only thing I don't agree with is including Pokemon Snap. It's not a mainline game and it would be a terrible experience for Cohh since he has 0 connection to the Pokemon franchise.
Serotriptomine wrote:
Sun Jul 08, 2018 10:00 am
My first thoughts are about the titles in general.

Main series titles would naturally all be included.
I would personally include Pokemon Snap as a 2nd game as its just great.

I would say no mobile app titles, no pinball series, no trading card series.
No Ranger, Rumble, or Mystery Dungeon Games.
No Pokemon PC titles.
No Console Pokemon games (Stadium, Colosseum, Revolution, Tournament, Quest)

The question is do we want to spread votes across all games or focus on the pairs?
Example.

Red & Blue & Yellow
Gold & Silver
Ruby & Sapphire
Diamond & Pearl
Black1`2 & White 1`2
X & Y
Sun & Moon.

This would effectively have the vote be based on Pokemon Generation.
After a generation is voted on, you could then split the vote again to community choose one or the other, or let Cohh choose which boxart looks more badass. :p

Or.
You could list them all by themselves

This isn't an official statement, just my personal opinion on what could be done in regards to option.

We'll also need more information about which games on what hardware and what version and how to do this for Cohh if anyone could help with that.

Re: Cohh's Pokemon Game Stream Poll

Posted: Mon Jul 30, 2018 9:40 am
by Serotriptomine
As it stands just focus on voting for the options available.

If for instance, Red is chosen. Moderators will look at all available Red versions and choose or let chat choose or Cohh choose the platform / version of Red.

(This includes all games not listed, i.e. the remakes / single enhanced "directors cut" releases)

All spin-off pokemon titles EXCEPT for Pokemon Snap have been excluded.

You have 2 votes, so use them on what you WANT TO SEE, or WANT CHAT TO SEE, or WANT COHH TO SEE (For 2 hours)

He may like the games, but I highly doubt (97.5% certain) he will ONLY spend 2 hours in these Pokemon games. Yes. I know, that isn't a lot of time to experience a Pokemon ->RPG<- But what can we do? :p

I originally wanted multiple polls in order to be more* accurate but this is what was settled on, between swiftness and accuracy. Hopefully that clears up all the confusion / questions. - Also, don't be disheartened if your favorite option doesn't have many votes (yet) this is still really early and the moment we sit down and tell everyone to connect with twitch and vote and Cohh shows it on screen it'll [hopefully] tally like crazy!

(No need to list your reasoning as to why x/y/z should be included, the options are already made and they are up there.)

Re: Cohh's Pokemon Game Stream Poll

Posted: Tue Jul 31, 2018 8:50 am
by YeKrazyGamer
FeelsBadMan No Pokemon Emerald FeelsBadMan

Mod Edit: If Ruby or Sapphire are chosen, Emerald is an option / possibility.

Re: Cohh's Pokemon Game Stream Poll

Posted: Tue Jul 31, 2018 4:45 pm
by Alysante
It will be a great day whatever game is choosen :cohhGG:

As long as he goes with Squirtle :cohhPts:

Re: Cohh's Pokemon Game Stream Poll

Posted: Wed Aug 01, 2018 4:05 am
by RagnarozSR
And as long as the game is not Snap. :cohhLUL:

Re: Cohh's Pokemon Game Stream Poll

Posted: Wed Aug 01, 2018 9:28 am
by sir_lobster
I see a lot of people have mentioned it but it really can't be overstated: If Red is chosen, play remake. If we all take off our nostalgia-glasses we can agree Red is an old game that hasn't aged well. Red was my first Pokemon game and I loved it, but no reasons not to play remake instead :cohhHmm: